The Melody Inn (affectionately known as “The Mel” to regulars) has been an Indianapolis fixture since the Great Depression, though its current incarnation as a punk and rock haven began in the 1990s.

For the decisionally challenged (or the wisely ambitious), the Whole Hog Platter delivers a triumvirate of barbecue excellence—pulled pork, beef brisket, and baby back ribs—alongside beans, potato ...