Jennifer Crumbley attends a motion as she is looking for a new trial in her case in front of Oakland County Judge Cheryl Matthews a the Oakland County Court House in Pontiac on Friday, Jan. 31, 2025.

Judge Cheryl Matthews listens to defense attorney Shannon Smith and her client Jennifer Crumbley, April 9, 2024, in Pontiac, Mich.

Oakland County Judge Cheryl Matthews reads James and Jennifer Crumbley their sentences for their role in the 2021 Oxford School shooting on Tuesday, April 9, 2024.

In a three-page ruling Wednesday, Oakland County Circuit Judge Cheryl Matthews sided with lawyers for James and Jennifer Crumbley, concluding the shooter has no right to his parents' confidential ...

Cheryl Ann Matthews Jul. 11, 1965 Feb. 5, 2014 Resident of Bay Point She leaves to cherish her memory: Companion, Dwight Lewis; six children, Allen Willis, ...

James Crumbley, left, stands with his attorney Mariell Lehman as Oakland County Judge Cheryl Matthews swears in the jury before Crumbley's trial on Thursday, March. 7, 2024.

In her eight-page order issued Tuesday, Oakland County Circuit Judge Cheryl Matthews wrote that she "clearly does not have jurisdiction" to decide whether McDonald should be disqualified from the ...

Matthews said a decision about whether there should be new trials is weeks away. Judge Cheryl Matthews has not yet decided whether Jennifer and James Crumbley should get new trials.

In her eight-page order issued Tuesday, Oakland County Circuit Judge Cheryl Matthews wrote that she "clearly does not have jurisdiction" to decide whether McDonald should be disqualified from the ...